Question:
I think prong collars are horrible. If people can't make an effort to properly socialize their dog and teach it basic obedience (and walking on a leash is basic doggie manners), then they shouldn't have a dog. I have a hard time keeping my thoughts to myself when I pass someone walking a dog with a prong (pinch) collar.
Pet stores shouldn't be allowed to sell them. And if a person is going to insist on putting one on their dog, it should only be done AFTER consulting with an experienced dog trainer who can show the individual how to put it on the dog, and explain that it should be worn for walking only.
What do you think?


Answer:
As you know, I TOTALLY agree with you!! With all of the other options out there (Promise collars, Haltis etc.) there is no need for those ones.


Answer:
you'll have to forgive my ignorance here ... I'm not a dog owner
What exactly is a prong collar? I think I get the idea, but a little explanation would be great ! Thanks


Answer:
Prong collars are made of stainless steel and have spikes all around the inside that dig into the dog's neck when they pull against the leash. They are often seen on large breeds like rottis & pitbulls. In my opinion, they should be banned. Often used by "macho" type guys who want their dog to look tough. Instead of actually teaching the dog to walk properly without this abusive method.


Answer:
Yikes, That sounds painful.
How would you compare the "comfort level" (if there is one) with that of a choke chain?


Answer:
I'm not a dog but I would think having spikes digging into my throat would be worse than a choke chain. My preference would be the Promise Collar which is fitted around the muzzle. We use these on all the large dogs at our shelter and it takes only a short time for the dog to get used to the feeling of it around their muzzle. Then we can have little old lady dogwalkers walking a Rottweiller with no trouble at all (and it doesn't hurt the dog!!)


Answer:
Suzoo, what is the difference between a Promise collar and a halti?
My dog was trained using a choke chain. And although I was very leary of using it myself but under the supervision of an experienced trainer, I felt more comfortable. I have heard that haltis can also be dangerous if the owner jerks too hard and it can cause neck injury. I have never used one but they do sound like a good training device.
I think that prong collars also have their own time and place...HOWEVER, that is a very small percentage of the time.


Answer:
Haltis and Promise collars are basically the same thing...just different brand names


Answer:
Oh ok!


Answer:
Lupis are also great alternatives to prong collars: they are adjustable harnesses that convert forward pull into upward lift, & stop the dog from yanking the leash. My friend with the undisciplined border collie got one of these on my recommendation & now she can walk this formerly completely unmanagaeable dog.
Prong collars should be banned.